Vale, John Shelby Spong

Vale, John Shelby Spong

Controversial author and bishop John ‘Shelby’ Spong passed away in his sleep on 12 September. He was 90.

Bishop Spong was the author of dozens of books, including Jesus for the Non-Religious, Why Christianity Must Change or Die, and  He was ordained as an Episcopalian Priest at the end of 1955. He was later consecrated as the bishop of Newark in June 1976. He held this role until his retirement in 2000.

Tributes have flown in for Bishop Spong, who was an early advocate for a more progressive and inclusive Christianity that embraced women and LGBTI people into the life of the church.

The Westar Institute, Home of the Jesus Seminar, issued a statement that, “His work and witness have inspired and freed many Westar members and a generation of thoughtful people. May his memory be a blessing.”

Bishop Spong’s approach to scripture and those who disagreed with him saw him become reviled in some theological circles, however.

For example, he believed that the virgin birth was a purely symbolic event and “no big deal” when it came to Christian faith.

Spong viewed Jesus’ resurrection in a similar way. In an interview with Religion News Services, “I don’t think the Resurrection has anything to do with physical resuscitation.”

“I think it means the life of Jesus was raised back into the life of God, not into the life of this world, and that it was out of this that his presence” — not his body — “was manifested to certain witnesses.”

Against this point, Sojourners founder Jim Wallace said that, for whom the gospel remains a dangerous claim on their lives, he resurrection is a vindication that a metaphorical approach would deny.

[T]hat debate is often a mostly intellectual one, with heady arguments flying back and forth, and usually ends up quite unresolved. Their sincere question prompted a different response in me. I simply asked a question back: “In the heat of South Africa’s oppression and the heart of apartheid’s despair, do you think that a merely metaphorical resurrection would have been enough for Desmond Tutu? It wouldn’t have been for me.” Mere intellectual debates aren’t enough when it comes to faith. It is what we face in our real lives and in the real world that has the most capacity to deepen our faith.

Bishop Spong worked during his time as an Episcopal priest to, in his terms, place scripture into its historical and literary context, moving away from a literal understanding of the event. He says that this approach to scripture saw attendance at his church grow.

“When people hear it, they grab on to it,” Bishop Spong said. “They could not believe the superstitious stuff and they were brainwashed to believe that if they could not believe it literally they could not be a Christian.”

Despite this, the Diocese of Newark’s membership levels halved during his episcopate, according to the diocese’s records.

Insights interviewed Bishop Spong during a promotional tour in 2007. At the time, he expressed contentment with his life, which involved a busy speaking and writing schedule.

However, the visit had been the subject of controversy, after then Anglican Archbishop of Sydney, Peter Jensen, banned Bishop Spong from appearing at any of the diocese’s churches.

Uniting Church theologian and With Love to the World Editor Rev. Dr John Squires wrote that, while he disagreed with much of what Bishop Spong wrote, his ideas deserved to be engaged with thoughtfully.

“Spong himself attributed great significance to the scholarly work of New Testament scholar Rudolph Bultmann and theologian Paul Tillich,” Rev. Dr Squires wrote.

“We can’t avoid grappling with the important ideas that these scholars advocated and explained. Both demythologisation (Bultmann’s key idea) and existentialist theology (Tillich’s central contribution) need to be engaged with, explored, and critiqued—not just dismissively brushed aside with slogans and stereotypes,”

“At the end of his life, let’s acknowledge the fine work that John Shelby Spong did in popularising and making widely known an extensive set of insights about what it means to have an informed faith that “makes sense” in the contemporary world; and let’s give thanks for his ministry of deepening and broadening the whole Christian exploration of scripture, faith, and discipleship.”

Insights sends condolences to Bishop Spong’s family and friends.


2 thoughts on “Vale, John Shelby Spong”

  1. Frances C Robinson

    Well, that wasn’t very nice of you, was it. Look, I know that there were things that didn’t quite jell. For instance — and No. 1 — he didn’t leave The Church. And he needed to do so to be taken more seriously. Well, for me, that’s the No. 1 problem. (When I stopped believing in traditional Christianity, I left. I haven’t belong to a church/parish in 52 years.) If he ever clearly said why he didn’t leave, I haven’t read along into it (I’m reading all of his books in chronological order). But as I read his autobiography, I realize that, from age 12-13, The Church was his whole life and all of his friends, some of decades, were in The Church. I can tell you, from experience, that ‘being out here all alone’ has been really scary at times (over the decades of my life). However, leave or stay — he had it wired. And the reason so many people were afraid of him — and they were afraid of him — is because clerics would have lost their cushy jobs (if they had agreed with him) and because the laity can’t live without answers to Ultimate Questions (Were did I come from? Why was I born? What is the purpose of my life? What happens to me when I die? etc., etc., etc.). Carl Jung said human beings can’t bear too much reality. “They would rather live with falsehoods, fear and guilty than live without traditional Christianity and the answers to The Ultimate Questions. I think he was almost always 100% correct. The Virgin Birth didn’t happen, Mary wasn’t a virgin, Jesus wasn’t God, the physical Resurrection didn’t happen, Heaven and Hell don’t exist, and, outside of a good physics textbook, we don’t know who or what God is. I think as Christianity progresses and evolves Bishop Spong will take his rightful place in the history of Christianity.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top